Columbus Crew II
Columbus CrewColumbus CrewColumbus CrewColumbus Crew II3–2Atlanta United II
Columbus Crew2–1FC Cincinnati
Columbus Crew1–2New York City FC
Columbus Crew2–0Atlanta United FC
Philadelphia Union1–1Columbus Crew
New York Red Bulls3–2Columbus CrewColumbus Crew2–1Los Angeles Galaxy
New England Revolution2–1Columbus CrewColumbus Crew0–0Chicago Fire
Sporting Kansas City2–2Columbus Crew
Portland Timbers3–2Columbus Crew
Seattle Sounders FC1–1Columbus CrewColumbus Crew0–0New York City FCColumbus Crew4–2Chicago Fire
